Strength and Durability Performance of Mortars Incorporating Calcined Clay as Pozzolan in Comparison with silica fume

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of Road, Housing & Urban Development Research Center, Tehran, Iran.

2 School of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

The use of low-grade calcined clays is the only potential material available in large quantities to meet the requirements of eco-efficient supplementary cementitious materials by decreasing the clinker content in blended types of cement or cement content in concrete. In the present paper, six mortar mixtures with a constant w/b ratio were used to investigate the mechanical and durability properties of mixtures substituted with low-grade calcined clays with/without limestone compared to PC and silica fume mixtures. The results obtained show that using calcined clays with low or intermediate purity (i.e., kaolinite content) leads to enhanced durability properties besides the comparable strength development characteristics compared to PC mortar. In this regard, the addition of 30% calcined clay with/without limestone led to a marked decrease (about 80 and 40%) in chloride ion diffusion coefficient (Da) and an increase in surface chloride content (Cs) compared to the reference mixture. In addition, the utilization of calcined clay with a kaolinite content of 56.7% led to a reduction of 52% in Da and an increase of 140% in electrical resistivity compared to silica fume binder. The primary reason for the better performance is attributed to the refined pore structure and dense microstructure of the cement paste with the calcined clay pozzolan compared to PC and silica fume.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Copyright © 2022 Ali Dousti. This is an open access paper distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License. Journal of Civil Engineering and Materials Application is published by Pendar Pub; Journal p-ISSN 2676-332X; Journal e-ISSN 2588-2880.

References

[1]  Flatt RJ, Roussel N, Cheeseman CR. Concrete: An eco material that needs to be improved. Journal of the European Ceramic Society. 2012 Aug 1;32(11):2787-98. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[2] Vizcaíno L, Antoni M, Alujas A, Martirena F, Scrivener K. Industrial manufacture of a low-clinker blended cement using low-grade calcined clays and limestone as SCM: the Cuban experience. InCalcined Clays for Sustainable Concrete: Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Calcined Clays for Sustainable Concrete 2015 May 8 (pp. 347-358). Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[3] Schneider M, Romer M, Tschudin M, Bolio H. Sustainable cement production—present and future. Cement and concrete research. 2011 Jul 1;41(7):642-50. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[4] Fernandez R, Martirena F, Scrivener KL. The origin of the pozzolanic activity of calcined clay minerals: A comparison between kaolinite, illite and montmorillonite. Cement and concrete research. 2011 Jan 1;41(1):113-22. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[5] Matschei T, Lothenbach B, Glasser FP. The role of calcium carbonate in cement hydration. Cement and concrete research. 2007 Apr 1;37(4):551-8. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[6] Rodrıguez-Camacho RE, Uribe-Afif R. Importance of using the natural pozzolans on concrete durability. Cement and concrete research. 2002 Dec 1;32(12):1851-8. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[7] Scrivener K, Martirena F, Bishnoi S, Maity S. Calcined clay limestone cements (LC3). Cement and Concrete Research. 2018 Dec 1;114:49-56. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[8] Avet F, Scrivener K. Investigation of the calcined kaolinite content on the hydration of Limestone Calcined Clay Cement (LC3). Cement and Concrete Research. 2018 May 1;107:124-35. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[9] Hollanders S, Adriaens R, Skibsted J, Cizer Ö, Elsen J. Pozzolanic reactivity of pure calcined clays. Applied Clay Science. 2016 Nov 1;132:552-60. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[10] Antoni M, Rossen J, Martirena F, Scrivener K. Cement substitution by a combination of metakaolin and limestone. Cement and concrete research. 2012 Dec 1;42(12):1579-89. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[11] Zolfagharnasab A, Ramezanianpour AA, Bahman-Zadeh F. Investigating the potential of low-grade calcined clays to produce durable LC3 binders against chloride ions attack. Construction and Building Materials. 2021 Oct 11;303:124541. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[12] Maraghechi H, Avet F, Wong H, Kamyab H, Scrivener K. Performance of Limestone Calcined Clay Cement (LC 3) with various kaolinite contents with respect to chloride transport. Materials and structures. 2018 Oct;51:1-7. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[13] Moodi F, Ramezanianpour AA, Safavizadeh AS. Evaluation of the optimal process of thermal activation of kaolins. Scientia Iranica. 2011 Aug 1;18(4):906-12. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[14] Beuntner N, Thienel KC. Properties of calcined lias delta clay—technological effects, physical characteristics and reactivity in cement. InCalcined Clays for Sustainable Concrete: Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Calcined Clays for Sustainable Concrete 2015 May 8 (pp. 43-50). Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[15] Dousti A, Beaudoin JJ, Shekarchi M. Chloride binding in hydrated MK, SF and natural zeolite-lime mixtures. Construction and Building Materials. 2017 Nov 15;154:1035-47. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[16] Zunino F, Scrivener K. The reaction between metakaolin and limestone and its effect in porosity refinement and mechanical properties. Cement and Concrete Research. 2021 Feb 1;140:106307. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[17] Hanein T, Thienel KC, Zunino F, Marsh AT, Maier M, Wang B, Canut M, Juenger MC, Ben Haha M, Avet F, Parashar A. Clay calcination technology: state-of-the-art review by the RILEM TC 282-CCL. Materials and Structures. 2022 Jan;55(1):3. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[18] Shekarchi M, Bonakdar A, Bakhshi M, Mirdamadi A, Mobasher B. Transport properties in metakaolin blended concrete. Construction and Building Materials. 2010 Nov 1;24(11):2217-23. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[19] Alujas A, Fernández R, Quintana R, Scrivener KL, Martirena F. Pozzolanic reactivity of low grade kaolinitic clays: Influence of calcination temperature and impact of calcination products on OPC hydration. Applied Clay Science. 2015 May 1;108:94-101. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[20] Avet F, Snellings R, Diaz AA, Haha MB, Scrivener K. Development of a new rapid, relevant and reliable (R3) test method to evaluate the pozzolanic reactivity of calcined kaolinitic clays. Cement and Concrete Research. 2016 Jul 1;85:1-1. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[21] Ferreiro S, Canut MM, Lund J, Herfort D. Influence of fineness of raw clay and calcination temperature on the performance of calcined clay-limestone blended cements. Applied Clay Science. 2019 Mar 1;169:81-90. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[22] Zunino F, Martirena F, Scrivener K. Limestone Calcined Clay Cements (LC³). ACI Materials Journal. 2021 May 1;118(3). [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[23] Dhandapani Y, Sakthivel T, Santhanam M, Gettu R, Pillai RG. Mechanical properties and durability performance of concretes with Limestone Calcined Clay Cement (LC3). Cement and Concrete Research. 2018 May 1;107:136-51. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[24] Berodier ES, Scrivener K. Understanding the Filler Effect on the Nucleation and Growth of C‐S‐H. Journal of the American Ceramic Society. 2014 Dec;97(12):3764-73. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[25] Bentz DP, Sato T, De la Varga I, Weiss WJ. Fine limestone additions to regulate setting in high volume fly ash mixtures. Cement and Concrete Composites. 2012 Jan 1;34(1):11-7. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[26] Badogiannis E, Kakali G, Dimopoulou G, Chaniotakis E, Tsivilis S. Metakaolin as a main cement constituent. Exploitation of poor Greek kaolins. Cement and Concrete Composites. 2005 Feb 1;27(2):197-203. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[27] Vejmelková E, Keppert M, Rovnaníková P, Keršner Z, Černý R. Application of burnt clay shale as pozzolan addition to lime mortar. Cement and Concrete Composites. 2012 Apr 1;34(4):486-92. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[28] Castillo R, Fernández R, Antoni M, Scrivener K, Alujas A, Martirena JF. Activación de arcillas de bajo grado a altas temperaturas. Revista ingeniería de construcción. 2010;25(3):329-52. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[29] Akindahunsi AA, Avet F, Scrivener K. The Influence of some calcined clays from Nigeria as clinker substitute in cementitious systems. Case Studies in Construction Materials. 2020 Dec 1;13:e00443. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[30] Antoni M. Investigation of cement substitution by blends of calcined clays and limestone. EPFL; 2013. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[31] Pillai RG, Gettu R, Santhanam M, Rengaraju S, Dhandapani Y, Rathnarajan S, Basavaraj AS. Service life and life cycle assessment of reinforced concrete systems with limestone calcined clay cement (LC3). Cement and Concrete Research. 2019 Apr 1;118:111-9. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[32] Parashar A, Bishnoi S. Hydration behaviour of limestone-calcined clay and limestone-slag blends in ternary cement. RILEM Technical Letters. 2021 Mar 19;6:17-24. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[33] Tang J, Wei S, Li W, Ma S, Ji P, Shen X. Synergistic effect of metakaolin and limestone on the hydration properties of Portland cement. Construction and Building Materials. 2019 Oct 30;223:177-84. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[34] Krishnan S, Emmanuel AC, Bishnoi S. Hydration and phase assemblage of ternary cements with calcined clay and limestone. Construction and Building Materials. 2019 Oct 20;222:64-72. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[35] Dousti A, Shekarchi M. Effect of exposure temperature on chloride-binding capacity of cementing materials. Magazine of Concrete Research. 2015 Aug;67(15):821-32. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[36] Guo Y, Zhang T, Tian W, Wei J, Yu Q. Physically and chemically bound chlorides in hydrated cement pastes: a comparison study of the effects of silica fume and metakaolin. Journal of Materials Science. 2019 Feb;54:2152-69. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[37] Bakera AT, Alexander MG. Use of metakaolin as supplementary cementitious material in concrete, with focus on durability properties. RILEM Technical Letters. 2019 Nov 12;4:89-102. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[38] Bucher R, Cyr M, Escadeillas G. Performance-based evaluation of flash-metakaolin as cement replacement in marine structures–Case of chloride migration and corrosion. Construction and Building Materials. 2021 Jan 18;267:120926. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[39] Sui S, Georget F, Maraghechi H, Sun W, Scrivener K. Towards a generic approach to durability: Factors affecting chloride transport in binary and ternary cementitious materials. Cement and Concrete Research. 2019 Oct 1;124:105783. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[40] Nguyen QD, Afroz S, Castel A. Influence of calcined clay reactivity on the mechanical properties and chloride diffusion resistance of limestone calcined clay cement (LC3) concrete. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering. 2020 Apr 25;8(5):301. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[41] Scrivener K, Snellings R, Lothenbach B, editors. A practical guide to microstructural analysis of cementitious materials. Boca Raton, FL, USA:: Crc Press; 2016. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[42] Vizcaino Andres LM, Antoni MG, Alujas Diaz A, Martirena Hernandez JF, Scrivener KL. Effect of fineness in clinker-calcined clays-limestone cements. Advances in Cement Research. 2015 Oct;27(9):546-56. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[43] Souri A, Golestani-Fard F, Naghizadeh R, Veiseh S. An investigation on pozzolanic activity of Iranian kaolins obtained by thermal treatment. Applied Clay Science. 2015 Jan 1;103:34-9. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[44] Dousti A, Rashetnia R, Ahmadi B, Shekarchi M. Influence of exposure temperature on chloride diffusion in concretes incorporating silica fume or natural zeolite. Construction and Building Materials. 2013 Dec 1;49:393-9. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[45]  Khaghanpour R, Dousti A, Shekarchi M. Prediction of cover thickness based on long-term chloride penetration in a marine environment. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities. 2017 Feb 1;31(1):04016070. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[46] Rashetnia R, Dousti A, Khatami D, Ahmadi B, Shekarchi M. Effect of natural zeolite and silica fume as a pozzolanic materials on the chloride diffusion of concrete. InProc., Int. Congress 2012. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[47] Branch JL, Kosson DS, Garrabrants AC, He PJ. The impact of carbonation on the microstructure and solubility of major constituents in microconcrete materials with varying alkalinities due to fly ash replacement of ordinary Portland cement. Cement and Concrete Research. 2016 Nov 1;89:297-309. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[48] Khunthongkeaw J, Tangtermsirikul S, Leelawat T. A study on carbonation depth prediction for fly ash concrete. Construction and building materials. 2006 Nov 1;20(9):744-53. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[49] Shah V, Bishnoi S. Carbonation resistance of cements containing supplementary cementitious materials and its relation to various parameters of concrete. Construction and Building Materials. 2018 Jul 30;178:219-32. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
[50] Šavija B, Luković M. Carbonation of cement paste: Understanding, challenges, and opportunities. Construction and Building Materials. 2016 Aug 1;117:285-301. [View at Google Scholar]; [View at Publisher].
 
Journal of Civil Engineering and Materials Application
Volume 6, Issue 3
September 2022
Pages 159-174

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 11 May 2022
  • Revise Date: 24 June 2022
  • Accept Date: 27 July 2022
  • First Publish Date: 18 September 2022

Share

How to cite

Statistics