Quasi-Static and Dynamic Analysis of Vertical and Horizontal Displacements in Earth Dams (Case Study: Azadi Earth Dam)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Water Engineering and Hydraulic Structures, Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Ayatollah Ozma Borujerdi, Borujerd, Iran.

10.22034/jcema.2020.245947.1039

Abstract

Seismic analysis of earth and rockfill dams is generally done in two ways: quasi-static and dynamic. However, a quasi-static method with easy application and simple assumptions may lead to unsafe and uneconomical results. In the present study, two static and dynamic analyzes have been used nonlinearly using the Rayleigh Damping rule to calculate the settlement and horizontal displacement of Azadi Dam in the stages of the end of construction and steady-state seepage. Also, in numerical analysis, Abaqus software and a simple elastoplastic behavior model based on the Mohr-Coulomb criterion have been used. The seismic analysis results show that settlement is more sensitive to horizontal displacement, so that settlement at the upper, middle, and lower levels of the shell is 66%, 55%, and 52% more than horizontal displacement, respectively. The highest amount of settlement occurred in both quasi-static and dynamic states in the dam's upper levels, with the difference that in the dynamic state and the full reservoir, the upstream shell is more affected by settlement. Also, settlement in the dynamic analysis is 37% higher than the quasi-static analysis.

Keywords


[1] Ambraseys NN, Sarma SK. The response of earth dams to strong earthquakes. Geotechnique. 1967 Sep;17(3):181-213. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[2] Sarma SK. Seismic stability of earth dams and embankments. Geotechnique. 1975 Dec;25(4):743-61. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[3] Tsai PH, Hsu SC, Lai J. Effects of core on dynamic responses of earth dam. InSlope Stability, Retaining Walls, and Foundations: Selected Papers from the 2009 GeoHunan International Conference 2009 (pp. 8-13). [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[4] Tsompanakis Y, Lagaros ND, Psarropoulos PN, Georgopoulos EC. Simulating the seismic response of embankments via artificial neural networks. Advances in Engineering Software. 2009 Aug 1;40(8):640-51. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[5] Elia G, Amorosi A, Chan AH, Kavvadas MJ. Numerical prediction of the dynamic behavior of two earth dams in Italy using a fully coupled nonlinear approach. International Journal of Geomechanics. 2011 Dec 1;11(6):504-18.[View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[6] Mukherjee S. Seismic slope stability analysis of earth dam: Some modern practices. Int. J. Recent Adv. Mech. Eng.. 2013;2(1):41-50. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[7] Huang LJ, Sheen YN, Hsiao DH, Le DH. Quasisteady analysis of excavation backfilled with soil-based controlled low-strength material using finite element and boundary element methods. Inthe International Conference on Green Technology for Sustainable Development 2014 (pp. 30-31). [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[8] Panulinová E, Harabinová S. Methods for analyzing the stability of an earthen dam slope. InAdvanced Materials Research 2014 (Vol. 969, pp. 245-248). Trans Tech Publications Ltd. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[9] Bandini V, Biondi G, Cascone E, Rampello S. A GLE-based model for seismic displacement analysis of slopes including strength degradation and geometry rearrangement. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering. 2015 Apr 1;71:128-42. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[10] Luo J, Zhang Q, Li L, Xiang W. Monitoring and characterizing the deformation of an earth dam in Guangxi Province, China. Engineering Geology. 2019 Jan 8;248:50-60. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[11] Sukkarak R, Jongpradist P, Pramthawee P. A modified valley shape factor for the estimation of rockfill dam settlement. Computers and Geotechnics. 2019 Apr 1;108:244-56. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[12] Zhang JM, Yang Z, Gao X, Zhang J. Geotechnical aspects and seismic damage of the 156-m-high Zipingpu concrete-faced rockfill dam following the Ms 8.0 Wenchuan earthquake. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering. 2015 Sep 1;76:145-56. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[13] Rashidi M, Heidar M, Azizyan G. Numerical analysis and monitoring of an embankment dam during construction and first impounding (case study: Siah Sang Dam). Scientia Iranica. 2018 Apr 1;25(2):505-16. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[14] Gikas V, Sakellariou M. Horizontal deflection analysis of a large earthen dam by means of geodetic and geotechnical methods. In13th FIG international symposium on deformation measurements and analysis and 4th IAG symposium on geodesy for geotechnical and structural engineering 2008 May 12. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[15] Silvani C, Bonelli S, Philippe P, Désoyer T. Buoyancy and local friction effects on rockfill settlements: a discrete modelling. Computers & Mathematics with Applications. 2008 Jan 1;55(2):208-17. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[16] Karalar M, Çavuşli M. Evaluation of 3D Nonlinear Earthquake Behaviour of the Ilısu CFR Dam under Far-Fault Ground Motions. Advances in Civil Engineering. 2019 Jan 1;2019. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[17] Karalar M, Cavusli M. Examination of 3d long-term viscoplastic behaviour of a CFR dam using special material models. Geomechanics and Engineering. 2019;17(2):119-31. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[18] Karalar M, Cavusli M. Seismic effects of epicenter distance of earthquake on 3D damage performance of CG dams. Earthquakes and Structures. 2020;18(2):201-13. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[19] Kartal ME, Cavusli M, Sunbul AB. Assessing seismic response of a 2D roller-compacted concrete dam under variable reservoir lengths. Arabian Journal of Geosciences. 2017 Nov 1;10(22):488. [View at Google Scholar] ; [View at Publisher]
[20] Azadi Reservoir Dam Design, Studies of the second phase, seismicity and earthquake engineering of Abdan Faraz Consulting Engineers, West Regional Water Company, 2003.[View at Publisher]
[21] Zienkiewicz OC, Taylor RL, Zienkiewicz OC, Taylor RL. The Finite Element Method (McGrawHill, London). [View at Google Scholar]
[22] ABAQUS Theory Manual, version 6.11-3., 2011. Dassault Systems.[View at Publisher]